By Elizabeth Duve Dziva
From time immemorial, polygamy has been part of the social history of many African
communities. Yet today, the subject is often discussed with judgement, embarrassment or
outright condemnation. Some see it as a symbol disrespect and women abuse, yet others regard it
as an institution rooted in family history, religion and cultural identity. But before we condemn
or defend it, do we truly understand why our ancestors practiced it?
Historically, polygamy was not simply about a man’s desire for several women. In communities
where lineage, land, livestock and family continuity were central to community organization,
families could strengthen household security, establish alliances and increase labor force through
polygamy. Where childlessness occurred, taking another wife could be an alternative of
continuing the family line. This was before the advent of surrogacy and adoption which is today,
the most common way to counter the challenges associated with childlessness.
Among the Shangaan communities in Chikombedzi, Zimbabwe, clan elders would consult the
senior wife before arranging another marriage to address childlessness. In some traditional
arrangements, the first wife could even suggest that her husband take another wife. Some
accounts describe senior wives participating in identifying a suitable woman or approaching her
on behalf of their husbands. Historian and culturalist Arnold Nkala explains that the first wife
occupied an important position in traditional polygamous negotiations.
However, this does not mean every woman welcomed another wife, but it challenges the
assumption that the practice always operated through unilateral male decisions. It’s also essential
to note that polygamous arrangements were not always successful and did not automatically
guarantee fairness, happiness or equal power for every woman. Cases of suicide, murder and
witchcraft were also very common.
Christianity introduced another layer of complexity. The Bible records polygamous households,
including King Solomon, who is described as having 700 wives and 300 concubines (1 Kings
11:3). Also, the story of Ruth and Boaz also records a marriage celebrated by the community,
although Boaz was already married. Yet, Paul’s instruction that there should be “one husband for
one wife” (1 Timothy 3:2) raises questions about how Christian communities interpret marriage.
Is this a universal prohibition of polygamy, or a specific qualification for the church at that time?
Christians have interpreted these passages differently. Paul also seems to contradict himself in 1
Corinthians 7 where he even encourages celibacy instead of marriage. This kind of confusion is
often attributed to Paul’s personal experiences by some critics who point that Paul had been
abandoned by his lover under some difficult circumstances hence his mixed emotions about
women and marriage.
Colonialism and missionary influence further changed African marriage institutions. European
Christian ideals often privileged monogamy, while colonial administrations introduced laws and
employment arrangements that favoured formally registered marriages. In colonial Zimbabwe’s
security forces, for example, only one wife at a time could reside in police camps. Such
examples demonstrate how colonial institutions could reshape family arrangements, although
they do not prove that every African community was forced to abandon polygamy.
Zimbabwe’s current law reflects this historical tension. The Marriages Act of 2022 states that
civil marriages are monogamous, while customary marriages may be polygamous or potentially
polygamous, subject to the relevant customary law. It also requires free and full consent to
marriage.
In modern societies, women in polygamous situations are contemptuously nicknamed Marwei or
“side chicks” and “chickens” (when above 30) or “side dishes”. Such expressions reduce and
sexualize women, suggesting that one is the main meal, yet, the other one is an optional and less
important meal. This reduces women, whether small or big house to sex objects whose role is
only to please men. Yet in reality, partnership is more than that.
Due to globalisation and continued technological advancement, online platforms have played a
significant role in what has become of this cultural practice of polygamy. Groups such as
Marriage Diaries, Secrets and Confessions, Dandaro Ramadzimai Anhasi, where women
exchange relationship advice, reveal how women are negotiating these complicated realities,
sometimes supporting one another and sometimes reinforcing painful compromises. Sadly, in
most cases, most internet “aunts” do not apply their opinions in real life. Reality is, most of them
have come to terms with their polygamous situations. Yet those that take the advices seriously
have become victims or villains who then get involved murder or suicide. Today, there are
innumerable reports of couples axing each other to death, or mutilating each other’s genitals, in
some cases burning each other with boiling water or cooking oil. Of which, according to
statistics, approximately one in every ten women in Zimbabwe is in a polygamous setup. The
only difference is that some have been formally introduced to their co wives, some are yet to
discover and unfortunately, some might even die without knowing them. That’s the complexity
of life.
The widely acceptable notion is that, such practices have been eroded due to westernization.
Ironically, recently an American Christian religious leader, Prophet Israel Ford, founder of
LifeWorks Church in Wickliffein Ohio, USA married a second wife. His first wife, Lydia Ford,
introduced his second wife, Minister Shakayla Ford (formerly Shakayla Talley), to the
congregation during a church service on 25 October 2026. She introduced her as her “sister in
marriage”. This therefore poses more questions than answers to this subject of polygamy.
In our contemporary society, there is also a public-health dimension of polygamy. Research
conducted in eastern Zimbabwe between 1998 and 2011 found that polygynous men reported
more casual sexual partnerships than monogamously married men. The researchers cautioned
against treating polygamy as automatically safe from HIV transmission. Yet, this does not mean
polygamy inevitably causes HIV infection. Rather, it reminds us that honesty, HIV testing,
protection, informed consent and responsibility matter.
Zimbabwean novelist Sue Nyathi confronts the darker side of contemporary multiple
relationships in her novel, The Polygamist (2012). One character describes Jonasi, the central
character as “greedy, selfish prick and we would never be able to satiate his desires.” The
statement invites us to consider what happens when multiple relationships are driven by secrecy
and selfishness rather than mutual understanding and responsibility. This is how different the
traditional polygamous practice was from that of today.
At the end of the day, the question is not simply whether polygamy is right or wrong. It about
openness, consent and being responsible. On the other hand, understanding our heritage does not
require us to accept every practice unquestioningly. It requires us to examine its history,
recognises its complexities and ask what values deserve to survive. Before we condemn our
ancestors or imitate them, perhaps we should first understand the reasons behind some of their
cultural practices and assess if they are worth carrying forward.
Elizabeth Duve Dziva is an archaeologist, cultural heritage practitioner, and History and
English educator. The views and opinions expressed in this article are solely those of the
author and do not necessarily represent those of any organisation. For further information,
please contact: duveelizabeth@gmail.com.
